How can we know if an asteroid will hit the ground?

You have undoubtedly seen this kind of news story: “Astronomers say that Space Rock can hit the ground in the not too distant future!” We usually see such warnings about one or two objects every year; The latest iteration relates to an asteroid, 2024 YR4, which can be up to 100 meters wide, and from this writing a greater than 2 percent chance of beating our planet by 2032.

But how can anyone know such things? How do astronomers find these asteroids and then decide where they will be many years to come?

We have actually known how to do this for centuries thanks to German astronomer Johannes Keplerthat first figured out of the necessary orbital laws in the 17th century. Since that time, the emergence of better telescopes, digital cameras and fast computers has made the task much easier – though in no way foolproof.


About to support science journalism

If you enjoy this article you may consider supporting our award winning journalism of subscription. By buying a subscription, you help ensure the future of effective stories about the discoveries and ideas that shape our world today.


There is about a dozen at the moment the operation of the type of study-telescopic observatories that take wide-angle images of the sky every night and look for undiscovered objects that zipped through our solar system. Seen from Earth, such objects appear to be moving relative to the far more distant “fixed” stars. Astronomers used to look for such movements by eyeing photographs, but automation can now perform this task much faster and more precisely.

Once a new moving object is found, its orbit must be determined. Is it on a circular path out past Mars, or does it have an elliptical trajectory that brings it close to the ground? This is where Kepler and his laws come in.

He figured out that all circuits have one of three forms: elliptical, parabolic or hyperbolic. (A circle is just an ellipse where the long and short axes are the same, so we clump circles in with ellipses.) Parabolic and hyperbolic lanes are what we call “open”, which means they don’t shut back on themselves . An object on such a trajectory just passes through; It moves fast enough to escape the gravity of the sun and disappear into the interstellar space. Most comets that fall against the sun from Beyond Neptune have almost parabolic circuits. Only two items are ever found on extreme hyperbolic circuits: ‘Oumuamua and Comet 2/iborisov.

But an object on an elliptical trajectory is tied to the sun and should cire it indefinitely (unless it gets a center of gravity from a planet, says). Our ability to predict the future position of a solar-orbiting object comes from understanding everything we can about its ellipse.

The basic properties of an orbital ellipse are its size (mathematical, half of the length of its long axis, a measurement called the “semi -axis”), its eccentricity (which essentially measures how elliptical it is: 0 is circular and 1 is infinitely stretched out as a line) and its orientation in the room. An object’s orbital ellipse can be tiped relative to the earth’s, for example, with its long axis pointed in a certain direction in the room. When we know all these parameters (called the Orbital items), we can mathematically define the associated ellipse. If we also know an asteroid’s position along its ellipse at some point, say, the date it was discovered or during a subsequent observation, Kepler’s equations tell us where along its orbit the asteroid should be on any Time – in theory.

In practice, it’s not that easy. Forecasts usually need at least three well -separated observations of an asteroid to start spiking all variables that control the shape of the ellip. And these observations are not accurate: Asteroids do not look like perfect small dots in a picture, but instead smeared out a bit, making it difficult to know their exact position when it changes against the background stars.

Such imprecise may be small, but they add. So the result is usually not an ideal ellipse, and the calculated path for the asteroid is unclear; In reality, its position can be a little away from the predicted place. The further into the future (or past, for that matter) you try to calculate the position, the worse the prediction becomes. It is like the actual path of the asteroid is a cone with its peak in the current position that opens in the direction you are trying to predict. Statistically, the rock could be everywhere inside this cone and it can add a large volume of space.

The predicted trajectory of the Asteroid 2024 YR4 animated in 3-month intervals per Frame that begins on December 22, 2024 and ends on December 22, 2032

The predicted course of the Asteroid 2024 YR4 as animated at 3-month intervals per Frame, which begins on December 22, 2024 and ended on December 22, 2032.

The only way to narrow down this path is to get more observations, either fresh from telescopes or recurring can be found in archive data. The longer the stretch of an object is observed, the more secure its orbital element measurements become.

It’s like being an outfielder in a baseball game. Imagine that the jug throws the ball, but for a second, after the dough hits it, you have to close your eyes and guess where it will be so you can catch it. You can make a decent estimate, but it will not be anywhere near the exact enough to guide you. You need to be able to keep an eye on the ball and watch as it moves to maximize your chances of catching the catch.

So we continue to observe asteroids as long as possible to increase the temporal baseline of observations. However, it is not always possible: Some asteroids are small and quickly fall into the brightness as our mutual distance increases. This is the case in 2024 YR4, which is now moving away from Earth and is expected to fade from sight in late April. Asteroids can also avoid observation by getting so close to the sun in the sky that they cannot be seen for months.

If we assume that an asteroid course is well limited and predictable, how do we know what the odds are for a soil impact? There are many methods of calculating this, but one way is to simulate trajectory and note the dates it is placed in the Earth’s orbital closeness, and then determine if our planet will actually be on its way at the same time. If so, that’s bad.

But it is not necessarily disastrous. The Earth is a small target and the statistical space volume that the asteroid can be on this date is usually large. So even for a seemingly alarming asteroid, there is only a chance that we will have influence, and it is usually very low, especially the longer in advance we try to predict it. Typically, the odds of the influence of any newly won potentially earthy space rock is one in thousands.

In most cases, better observations nail down the path and show that it goes far away from the ground and the odds fall effectively to zero. Annoying, the statistical chance of influence sometimes increases First – which is what happened to 2024 YR4 in recent days. Remember, the asteroid is a place near the peak of a large cone and we don’t know where. If the Earth is near the midline of the cone, narrow when the cone is narrowed with better observations, We are still inside that. The chance of influence goes up. But then, almost always, the cone narrows further and wins up pointing in a slightly different direction, leaving the soil safe outside it, and we can all inhale the sigh of relief.

That is not to say that we are never affected! Recent examples are teeming, such as Chelyabinian asteroid in 2013, Tunguska event in 1908 and the influence that formed Arizona’s Meteor crater 50,000 years ago. Every day the soil plows through approx. 100 tonnes of interplanetary material, the vast majority of which are composed of small cliffs that win up as lovely meteors that contradict our sky. But sometimes these piles of waste are bigger – sometimes very Larger. The bigger they get, the rarer they become, so really devastating effects are few and far in between.

But they happen so we have to keep an eye on the sky. The good news is that even more telescopes come online, including the huge Vera C. Rubin Observatory In Chile and NASA’s Neo Surveyor (Scheduled for launch in 2027) that should help us not only map where these objects are and where they are on their way but also determine their size and what they are made of. If some asteroids that are big enough to hurt, have us in its cross chairs, hopefully we know about it as soon as we can, giving us enough time to do something about it.

The more telescopes we have that cover the most amount of sky over time, the better.